‘Carnival of Rust’ by Poets of the Fall is more than just a song; it’s an experience that blends haunting melodies with profound lyrical depth. The accompanying music video, directed by Stobe Harju, elevates the song to another level by weaving a rich tapestry of visual storytelling that enhances and complements the themes of the song. Through its intricate use of symbolism, colour, and character representation, the video transforms ‘Carnival of Rust’ into a mesmerizing narrative that explores themes of decay, disillusionment, and the relentless passage of time.
The Setting: A Metaphor for Emotional Decay
The music video opens in a dilapidated, surreal carnival—a setting that immediately sets the tone for the visual narrative. The carnival, once a place of joy and wonder, is now a decaying ruin, symbolizing the erosion of happiness and the disillusionment that comes with the harsh realities of life. The deteriorating environment serves as a powerful metaphor for the emotional decay experienced by the characters in the video, as well as the broader theme of disillusionment expressed in the song’s lyrics.
This decaying carnival is not just a backdrop but a character in its own right, reflecting the internal turmoil of the protagonists. The crumbling structures, rusted machinery, and desolate atmosphere all contribute to a sense of despair and loss, mirroring the feelings of the song’s narrator. The setting’s eerie, abandoned nature also evokes a sense of isolation, reinforcing the song’s themes of loneliness and the passage of time.
Symbolism and Visual Metaphors
Throughout the video, visual metaphors are employed to deepen the narrative and add layers of meaning to the song’s lyrics. One of the most striking symbols is the fortune teller, who represents fate and the inevitability of life’s challenges. As the fortune teller reveals the cards, the protagonist’s fate seems sealed, symbolizing the inescapable nature of their emotional journey.
Another powerful metaphor is the recurring image of a broken mirror. Mirrors in literature and film often symbolize self-reflection and truth, but in ‘Carnival of Rust,’ the shattered mirror represents a fractured self or the loss of one’s identity. This imagery resonates with the song’s exploration of how time and experiences can distort and break down the person we once were.
The video also features a dying rose, a classic symbol of lost love and the ephemeral nature of beauty and life. As the rose withers and decays, it reflects the central theme of the song: the inevitability of decay and the painful beauty of fleeting moments.
Colour Palette: A Study in Contrast
The colour palette in ‘Carnival of Rust’ is deliberately chosen to reflect the emotional undertones of the song. The video predominantly uses muted, desaturated colours, with shades of brown, grey, and rust dominating the scenes. These colours enhance the sense of decay and abandonment, creating a sombre, melancholic atmosphere that aligns with the song’s themes.
However, there are moments where colour is used to striking effect. For example, the red of the dying rose or the bright lights of the carnival rides stand out starkly against the muted background. These bursts of colour symbolize fleeting moments of life, passion, or joy—moments that are quickly consumed by the surrounding decay. The use of colour in this way not only highlights these moments but also underscores their transience.
Character Representation: Archetypes of Emotion
The characters in the ‘Carnival of Rust’ music video are not just individuals; they are archetypes representing different facets of human emotion and experience. The fortune teller, as mentioned, embodies fate and the inevitability of life’s hardships. The clown, often associated with joy and entertainment, in this video takes on a more tragic role, representing the façade people often wear to hide their true feelings of despair and sadness.
The lead singer, Marko Saaresto, is portrayed as a weary traveller or seeker, journeying through this landscape of decay and searching for meaning or redemption. His interactions with the other characters and the environment reflect the internal struggle depicted in the song, as he grapples with the disillusionment and loss that the carnival represents.
Surrealism and Dreamlike Sequences
The music video incorporates elements of surrealism, blurring the lines between reality and fantasy. The distorted reality depicted in the video—with its strange characters, decaying setting, and dreamlike sequences—mirrors the song’s exploration of emotional turmoil and existential angst. This surreal quality allows the video to transcend a literal interpretation of the lyrics, offering instead a visual representation of the subconscious mind.
For instance, the scene where the protagonist interacts with the fortune teller feels more like a dream or vision than a real event. This surrealism enhances the overall narrative by allowing viewers to experience the song on a deeper, more symbolic level.
Narrative Structure and Progression
The narrative of the ‘Carnival of Rust’ music video unfolds gradually, mirroring the song’s progression from introspective melancholy to a climax of emotional intensity. The video’s pacing is deliberate, allowing viewers to absorb the rich symbolism and emotional weight of each scene. As the song builds to its crescendo, so too does the visual intensity, culminating in a powerful and evocative conclusion.
The video’s narrative progression is also cyclical, with the ending reflecting the beginning. This circular structure reinforces the theme of inevitability and the idea that life’s challenges and pains are an endless cycle—a carnival of rust that we are all part of.
Enhancing the Song’s Themes
The music video for ‘Carnival of Rust’ by Poets of the Fall is a masterclass in visual storytelling, using artistic and symbolic elements to enhance and deepen the song’s themes. Through its careful use of setting, colour, symbolism, and character representation, the video not only complements the song but also expands its narrative, offering viewers a rich and immersive experience. By blending surrealism with emotional depth, the ‘Carnival of Rust’ music video stands as a powerful companion to the song, turning a musical journey into a visual odyssey of decay, disillusionment, and the haunting beauty of life’s fleeting moments.
Also Read: 80s Musical Elements in ‘(I Just) Died in Your Arms’ by Cutting Crew
–Silviya.Y