‘Donnie Brasco’: Al Pacino Shines as a Real-Life Mobster in This Underrated Gangster Classic

Classics like ‘The Godfather’, ‘Goodfellas’, ‘Casino’, and ‘Once Upon a Time in America’ are frequently the first films that spring to mind when people talk about mob films. But ‘Donnie Brasco’ (1997) deserves a place among these classics. Away from the glitz and spectacle of its predecessors, the picture presents a direct, personal depiction of organized crime, with one of Al Pacino’s most subtle performances as real-life gangster Benjamin “Lefty” Ruggiero. 

‘Donnie Brasco’, which is celebrating its 27th year, is a powerful and realistic examination of the lives of elderly criminals and small-time hustlers who are merely trying to make ends meet.

Image Courtesy: Netflix

The film revolves around Lefty, a tired mafia enforcer who serves as a mentor to Johnny Depp’s undercover agent, Donnie Brasco, and is based on the real story of FBI agent Joseph D. Pistone’s infiltration of the Bonanno criminal family. Due to debt, family problems, and unmet goals, Lefty’s life is a never-ending battle. When Donnie’s secret identity is exposed, Lefty’s world falls apart despite his unwavering devotion to the mob. In a heartbreaking conclusion, Lefty silently gets ready for his impending doom, illustrating the psychological toll that betrayal takes.

Paul Attanasio’s screenplay skillfully blends action and character development, while director Mike Newell expertly strikes a balance between suspense and humanity. The psychological effects of Donnie’s double life are further emphasized by the film’s use of close-ups and handheld cameras.

Image Courtesy: IMDb

Despite the film’s artistic license with Ruggiero’s tale, Pacino’s portrayal effectively conveys Lefty’s devotion and traditional values. The actual Ruggiero, a more well-known member of the Bonanno family, had a less spectacular demise; he was imprisoned before passing away from cancer.

Al Pacino’s skill at giving morally grey characters nuance is still demonstrated by ‘Donnie Brasco’. This movie, which emphasizes the human cost of mob life over its appeal, is a must-see in an era of finding hidden gems because of its sophisticated writing and strong performances.

–Farheen Ali