How ‘In the Shadow of the Moon’ Blends Crime Thriller and Sci-Fi

‘In the Shadow of the Moon’, a 2019 film directed by Jim Mickle, is a unique hybrid of two seemingly contrasting genres: the gritty crime thriller and cerebral science fiction. At its core, the movie tells a story about a Philadelphia detective obsessed with solving a series of mysterious murders. But beneath the surface, it evolves into a time-bending narrative that explores fate, morality, and the far-reaching consequences of radical ideologies.

The film opens in 1988 with Detective Thomas Lockhart (played by Boyd Holbrook) chasing down a strange killer who appears to die, only to return every nine years and commit the same kind of murder. This setup feels like classic noir: a determined cop, a string of unexplained crimes, and a haunting personal cost. The procedural elements drive the early part of the story, grounding the audience in a familiar detective drama.

Image Courtesy: Netflix

As the timeline advances—to 1997, 2006, and beyond—the film slowly peels back its layers to reveal something much larger. The killer, Rya, is not just another criminal. She’s a time traveller from the future, attempting to alter history to prevent a catastrophic uprising sparked by the ideology of someone close to Lockhart. This twist gradually shifts the film from mystery to science fiction, but it does so without abandoning its suspense-driven roots.

What makes ‘In the Shadow of the Moon’ stand out is how it uses science fiction not just for spectacle, but for emotional and philosophical depth. The film poses challenging questions about free will, justice, and whether it's ever morally justifiable to intervene before someone commits a crime. These themes echo classics like ‘Minority Report’ and ‘12 Monkeys’, but the movie grounds them in a deeply personal journey.

Image Courtesy: Netflix

Lockhart’s obsession with solving the case spans decades, and his descent mirrors that of many noir protagonists. Yet, instead of being broken by corruption or guilt, he is driven by loss—of his wife, of his daughter’s childhood, and of his sense of control. The time travel element in 'In the Shadow of the Moon' ultimately reframes his story: what seemed like madness is revealed to be part of a tragic loop of sacrifice and understanding.

By blending genre conventions with a slow-burning sci-fi twist, ‘In the Shadow of the Moon’ delivers a story that is as emotionally resonant as it is intellectually intriguing. It’s not just a genre mashup—it’s a reflection on time, consequences, and the human cost of trying to change the future.