'Nightmare Alley': Discover Guillermo del Toro's Underrated Neo-Noir Gem

Though ‘Nightmare Alley’ lacks Guillermo del Toro's usual supernatural elements, it remains a hallucinatory and fantastical neo-noir gem. Set among the deceptive world of carnival workers, the film reveals harsh truths about human arrogance and the belief that we are all "special." Bradley Cooper's Stanton, along with the other characters, embodies this delusion, believing they are above ordinary reality. The film exposes our fragile self-image through a series of warnings and fantasies, forcing us to confront our insignificance.

Stanton's journey from cynicism to vanity-driven mentalism highlights his downfall. He starts in a carnival, grounded in hard labour to escape his past, but his growing arrogance blinds him to the dangers of manipulating others. His ambition leads him to con Ezra Grindle (Richard Jenkins) and trust Lilith Ritter (Cate Blanchett), a psychologist skilled in manipulation, ultimately resulting in his ruin. Stanton's ego, not Ritter's, is the true antagonist, showing how pride blinds us to our limits.

Also Read: Osgood Perkins’ ‘Gretel & Hansel’: A Horror Spin on a Classic Fairy Tale

The female characters add complexity to this commentary on pride. Molly (Rooney Mara) symbolizes humility, keeping Stanton grounded until his ambition drives them apart. Her belief in saving Stanton makes her a victim of her ego, but she ultimately reclaims her life. Ritter, the femme fatale, is powerful yet prideful, her final line "I'll live" revealing the futility of her vengeful pursuits.

‘Nightmare Alley’ critiques our delusions of uniqueness. Mentalism, which relies on reading universal human experiences, exposes our arrogance. The carnival setting, with its grotesque spectacles, mirrors our hypocritical vanity and lack of accountability. Set during the Great Depression and pre-WWII, the film shows how ego and fantasy offer escape from harsh realities but also lead to ruin.

Del Toro's departure from his typical supernatural themes in ‘Nightmare Alley’ showcases his versatility. Inspired by the original film and novel, del Toro delves into the dark underbelly of society, creating a compelling, non-supernatural story. 

–Farheen Ali