This is How 'Dune 2' Could Change Alia Atreides' Story in The Original Book

As the anticipation builds for 'Dune: Part Two,' whispers of a significant alteration involving Alia Atreides is stirring speculation among fans. Adapting the latter half of Frank Herbert's seminal novel, the sequel ostensibly has ample room for a faithful rendition.

However, the initial portrayal of Alia in 'Dune 2' suggests a departure from the source material, depicting her as an embryo offering counsel from the womb—an unexpected twist that could reverberate throughout the film's narrative landscape.

Alia, the sister of Paul Atreides, bears the weight of genetic memories and potent prescience, integral to the saga's unfolding. Should this deviation persist, 'Dune 2' may navigate pivotal deviations from Herbert's iconic text, check them out below.

Also Read: This is How ‘Deadpool 3’ Could Change The History Of The MCU

Lady Jessica Will Have A Longer Role in 'Dune 2'

One of the most significant changes from the source material lies in the fate of Alia, a character pivotal to the original narrative. With Alia's role potentially absorbed by Lady Jessica, the stage is set for a profound transformation in the storyline.

As speculation swirls about the extent of Lady Jessica's expanded role, it becomes apparent that she may inherit not only Alia's storylines but also her responsibilities, effectively assuming two distinct roles from the book. The prospect of Lady Jessica taking on Alia's most critical duty, such as confronting Baron Harkonnen, looms on the horizon, although uncertainties persist.

Whether Lady Jessica fully embraces Alia's narrative arc or merely incorporates elements from it remains to be seen. Nevertheless, as the sequel unfolds, the likelihood of Lady Jessica's heightened prominence emerges as a compelling narrative possibility, shaping the intrigue surrounding 'Dune: Part Two.'

Emperor Shaddam IV Might Not Have An Atreides Hostage

In Frank Herbert's novel 'Dune,' a pivotal moment occurs when Paul Atreides' son is killed in a raid and his sister Alia is captured to become a hostage of Emperor Shaddam IV. However, the upcoming adaptation faces a unique challenge: Alia's absence from the storyline of 'Dune 2.' Without her capture, a crucial element of Herbert's intricate plot is disrupted.

The Emperor's possession of an Atreides hostage is not only a significant plot point but also sets the stage for subsequent events, including Alia's pivotal role in the assassination of the Baron. If this narrative thread is severed in the movie adaptation, it could ripple through the story, necessitating drastic alterations.

While Lady Jessica remains a possible substitute hostage, her capture would still require substantial adjustments to maintain continuity with the source material.

Lady Jessica Will Be Pregnant Throughout 'Dune 2'

Without Alia's existence, Lady Jessica's prolonged pregnancy becomes a central focal point, altering the dynamics between characters and potentially reshaping their fates. Paul's heightened awareness of his mother's condition casts a protective shadow over their interactions, steering him towards prioritizing her safety, thus deepening his reliance on Chani.

However, Paul's efforts to shield his family may unwittingly lead to unforeseen consequences, echoing the tragic trajectory of the source material.

Paul and Chani Might Not Have a Son

As anticipation mounts for the sequel to 'Dune,' one burning question looms over fans: will Paul and Chani welcome a son as they do in the books? The uncertainty surrounding 'Dune 2''s narrative arc leaves us wondering if this pivotal aspect of the story will be mirrored on screen.

However, a closer look at the timeline presents a challenge: with Alia's birth closely tied to Leto Atreides' demise, the window for Paul and Chani's parenthood seems narrow. Moreover, the tragic fate awaiting their son in the Harkonnen raid raises doubts about his inclusion in the film, given the plethora of plotlines demanding attention.

Baron Harkonnen's Fate Will Be Different

Alia's absence in 'Dune 2' could reshape the fate of the villainous Baron Vladimir Harkonnen, posing intriguing possibilities for the storyline. In Frank Herbert's Dune novel, the climactic demise of the Baron comes at the hands of his granddaughter, Alia Atreides, yielding the iconic Gom Jabbar.

However, with Alia's role potentially limited due to her being an embryo, alternative scenarios emerge. Among the contenders, Lady Jessica emerges as a compelling choice to wield the lethal blow. If she were to eliminate the Baron while carrying Alia, it would align closely with the original narrative while emphasizing the theme of familial strife.

'Dune 2' Might Not Have A Major Time Jump

The potential alteration to Alia Atreides in 'Dune 2' could reshape the film's narrative landscape, potentially eliminating the necessity for a significant time jump. In Frank Herbert's novel, a pivotal two-year gap occurs after Paul's immersion into Fremen culture, primarily to allow him to gain sway among the Fremen and mobilize their resistance against the Harkonnens.

However, the crux of this hiatus lies in the birth of Alia. Traditionally, Alia's transformation, catalyzed by Lady Jessica's consumption of the Water of Life, predominantly manifests mentally, prompting Herbert to delay her storyline until she physically matures enough to articulate.

Yet, if 'Dune 2' were to portray Alia advising her mother from the womb, the narrative impetus for a prolonged time leap diminishes. While the sequel may still fast-forward to bolster the Fremen's allegiance to Paul, with Lady Jessica already pregnant, the leap forward in time would likely be considerably shorter.