Christian Bale's ‘American Psycho’ Co-Stars Initially Doubted His Performance

Christian Bale's performance in ‘American Psycho’ is now iconic, but it wasn't always seen that way by his co-stars. In a recent Vanity Fair interview commemorating the film's 25th anniversary, Josh Lucas and Chloë Sevigny shared their initial misgivings about Bale's acting choices during filming.

Josh Lucas, who portrayed Craig McDermott, admitted he initially thought Bale's performance was "terrible." Reflecting on their first scene together, Lucas recalled, "I watched him and he seemed so false." This sentiment was echoed by Sevigny, who, while not outright critical, found Bale's approach perplexing and felt "really intimidated" by his intensity.

Also Read: Christian Bale Unveiled as Frankenstein’s Monster in ‘The Bride’

Lucas, now 52, explained that with time, he came to understand the genius behind Bale's method. "I now realize that it was this just a brilliant choice that he was making," he said, noting how the film's director, Mary Harron, crafted a subversive satire that turned traditional expectations on their head.

Sevigny, who played Jean, the secretary of Bale’s character Patrick Bateman, confessed she was initially confused by Bale’s aloofness. "I was just kind of confused, like, Why aren’t you being social?" she shared. Despite feeling intimidated, Sevigny later appreciated Bale's dedication to his role, recognizing the depth and layers he brought to the character.

Both Lucas and Sevigny now see Bale's process in a new light. "I thought it was bogus acting at the time, but it was exactly the opposite," Lucas admitted, acknowledging Bale's exceptional talent and foresight. Sevigny, known for her roles in 'Boys Don't Cry' and 'Big Love,' appreciated Bale's commitment, though it challenged her on set.

Bale’s preparation for 'American Psycho' was extensive. He famously transformed his physique, admitting later that he "had never gone to a gym" before taking on the role. His portrayal of the psychopathic investment banker Patrick Bateman remains one of his most memorable performances, a testament to his intense dedication to his craft.

Sevigny mentioned that Leonardo DiCaprio was once considered for the role of Patrick Bateman. Reflecting on the film's legacy, she said, "I didn’t know it was going to become what it did and have the legs that it has had." The film has since become a cult classic, appreciated for its dark humour and social commentary.

The retrospective look at ‘American Psycho’ highlights how initial scepticism can give way to admiration as performances are understood in their full context. Christian Bale’s portrayal of Patrick Bateman is a prime example of an actor’s ability to make bold, unconventional choices that ultimately redefine a role and leave a lasting impact on audiences and co-stars alike.

-Gayathri J